Pumpkin Cutie Pies OR Filling for baked pumpkin pie – from scratch

pumpkin_cutie_pies_h (Copy)

Make pumpkin pie filling, or crust-less pumpkin cutie pies, from scratch- starting with a fresh “pumpkin” and ending up with dessert in under an hour.  The process is simple with our easy-cooking tips like using a measuring vessel as a mixing bowl and pouring pitcher with the ever-useful immersion blender (my favorite kitchen helper after the pressure cooker of course!).

No more soggy pies!
The trick to making your own pumpkin pie filling from a fresh pumpkin in the pressure cooker is managing all of the extra water the pumpkin retains during the steaming process. Some squash varieties are notorious water hoggers, while others are more dense. Having started my recipe testing with a water-hogger I can tell you that a pie (and even our cutie pies) will be a soggy failure if you don’t carefully squeeze the pulp. Even after doing all of the squeezing, I added corn starch to the recipe – extra insurance that nothing will go wrong during the special occasion for which you will be serving them.

That’s also why I went with butternut squash as the the primarily ingredient, here – it has a dense flesh that does not retain as much water compared to any ‘ol pumpkin. Plus, you already knew that canned “pumpkin pie filling” doesn’t contain any actual pumpkins, right? Save this factoid for dessert while everyone is “ooOOohing” and “hmMMming” about how delicious your pumpkin cutie pies are.

Why not a single crust-less pie?
crustless_pumpkien_pie (Copy)One of the first things I tried, was pressure cooking a whole 8″ crust-less pie.  The problem with doing that is that this is what Italians call a “spoon” dessert:  no way to un-mould it, and even if you managed to do it, the slices can’t really hold together on their own without the support of a crust. I don’t recommend making this dessert a whole “pie” because when it comes to serving you’ll have to scoop it out with a spoon and serve it as amorphous glops in a bowl – delicious but hideous for a special occasion!

So, that’s why we make individual cutie pies, which make more sense for your guests to scoop themselves!

scoop (Copy)


Pressure Cooker Accessories Pr. Cook Time Pr. Level Open
5L or larger steamer basket, heat-proof bowl(s) 3 & 8 min. High(2) Normal & 10-min. Natural

3.0 from 1 reviews
Mini crustless pumpkin pies OR Fresh Pumpkin Pie Filling - pressure cooker recipe
Nutritional Information
(per serving)
  • Serves: 8 ramekins or 1 pie
  • Serving size: ⅛th
  • Calories: 143.9
  • TOTAL Fat: 2.3g
  • Saturated fat: 0.9g
  • TOTAL Carbs: 29.1
  • Sugar Carbs: 19.0g
  • Sodium: 58.2mg
  • Fiber Carbs: 2.1g
  • Protein: 3.3g
  • Cholesterol: 54.8mg
Recipe type: pressure cooker
Cuisine: America
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Makes enough to fill eight 4oz (115ml) ramekins or to fill one 9-10 inch (22-25cm) pre-cooked pie crust. Make this recipe "Paleo" by replacing the milk with your favorite nut, or coconut milk and the corn starch with arrrowroot powder.
  • 2 lbs (1k) butternut squash, peeled and diced (or one 2-3lb sugar pumpkin, seeded and cut into manageable chunks - see special notes)
  • 1 cup (250ml) whole milk (or fresh cream, or coconut milk)
  • ¾ cup maple (185ml) 100% pure maple syrup
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 teaspoon powdered cinnamon
  • ½ teaspoon, powdered ginger ( or 1" piece fresh ginger, peeled & very finely chopped)
  • ¼ teaspoon powdered cloves
  • 1 tablespoon organic corn starch
  • 2 pinches sea salt
  • sweetened whipped cream
  • chopped pecans
  1. Prepare the pressure cooker by adding 1 cup (250ml) water, or your pressure cooker's minimum liquid requirement, and add the squash cubes the steamer basket and lower into the pressure cooker.
  2. Close the lid and set the valve to pressure cooking position.
    Electric pressure cookers: Cook for 4 minutes at high pressure (9 minutes for wedges).
    Stove top pressure cookers: Lock the lid, and cook for 3 minutes at high pressure (7 minutes for wedges).
  3. In the meantime, in a 4-cup measuring cup (1L pitcher) , or medium mixing bowl, measure out the milk, maple syrup, and then add the eggs, cinnamon, ginger, salt and corn starch. Beat, using a fork or an immersion blender, until the ingredients are well combined.
  4. When the pressure cooking time is up, open the cooker by releasing the pressure though the valve.
  5. Tumble the cooked butternut squash in a fine-mesh strainer (or peel cooked pumpkin and then strain) and once cooled (about 10 minutes) press on the squash pulp to release some liquid (save this liquid to use in place of stock in other recipes).
  6. Measure the strained pumpkin pulp by jamming it into a 2-cup measure (or weighing out 550g) - measure out and freeze or refrigerate the rest for future pumpkin pies or to plop into a pasta sauce or soup.
  7. Plop the pulp into the measuring cup with the egg mixture and blend well.
To make cute crust-less pies in the pressure cooker:
  1. Add 1 cup (250ml) water, or your pressure cooker's minimum liquid requirement, to the pressure cooker and steamer basket or trivet and set aside.
  2. Pour the mixture into heat-proof ramekins and lower into the pressure cooker un-covered - put the second layer on to of the first by balancing on the edges of the ramekins, below.
  3. Close the lid and set the valve to pressure cooking position.
    Electric pressure cookers: Cook for 10 minutes at high pressure.
    Stove top pressure cookers: Lock the lid, and cook for 8 minutes at high pressure.
  4. When time is up, open the pressure cooker with the 10-Minute Natural release method - move the cooker off the burner and wait for the pressure to come down on its own (about 10 minutes). For electric pressure cookers, when cooking time is up count 10 minutes of natural open time. Then, release the rest of the pressure slowly using the valve.
  5. Lift the ramekins out of the pressure cooker using tongs and let stand 5 minutes before serving or let cool completely, cover tightly and refrigerate for up to two days.
To fill a pre-cooked pie crust and bake:
  1. Preheat oven to 350°F/180°C
  2. Pour filling into a 9-inch baked pie crust and cover the edges only with a ring of foil. Bake on the center rack until center of the pie is just set (a clean toothpic comes out of the center), which will take 45 to 50 minutes.
  1. Serve with whipped cream and chopped pecans sprinkled on top.

Crustless Pumpkin Pie (or filling) - from scratch!Crustless Pumpkin Pies (or filling for a crust) - pressure cookedPressure Cooker Pumpkin Pie

To make your own pie crust, follow this super-easy adaptation of Julia Child’s pie crust using a cuisinart  (using a food processor).